How’s the Market? “Hot” or “Cold” – Understanding Today’s Reality 🧭
It’s the most common question I get when the market isn’t HOT: “Robert, how’s the market?” The question itself is insightful because, ironically, when the market IS IN extreme conditions – either crashing or in a full-blown frenzy – fewer people ask. The uncertainty of a balanced or normalizing market often causes the most anxiety.
So, are we in a decline, a correction, or on the verge of a crash? I don’t claim to have a crystal ball for future predictions 🔮. What I do know is that the economy is not as over levered to the housing market as it was in the 2008 Great Recession, and the overall economy seems to be in a better place (as of now). Many also forget in 2022 we did see a correction in the market due to the rate increases that happened that year, more than doubling from 3% to 7%.
The market today, influenced by mortgage rates generally fluctuating in the 6-7% range and ongoing stock market volatility (which significantly impacts our RSU-reliant Bay Area buyer pool), has “normalized.” Money isn’t “cheap” anymore and tightening underwriting guidelines makes mortgages more difficult to obtain, especially at the amounts buyers expect.
Buyers are still active and many can still afford current prices, especially in desirable areas like Danville and Pleasanton, but they are more discerning. Buyers want to feel their significant purchase investment is wise, now more than ever, given the broader economic uncertainties (think tariffs, inflation, geopolitics, wars, government debt levels, AI & job security, etc.).
— ✨ —
Premiums, Discounts, or Clearance: Where Does Your Home Fit?
In this current climate, not all homes perform equally. Consider the automotive market for as an analogy:
- Premium Offering (The New Luxury Model) 💎: Think of a brand new, highly sought-after luxury vehicle – the latest Porsche, the new Ferrari, or even the newest high tech family option like the Volvo XC40. These usually sell at or above MSRP, oftentimes with waiting lists. This parallels a home that is impeccably presented to create the demand: like-new condition, with on-trend (yet timeless) materials, in a prime location, and boasting an efficient, desirable floor plan that feels expansive. Such homes still create significant demand, often resulting in multiple offers and quick sales, sometimes exceeding asking price.
- Discount Potential (The Certified Pre-Owned Value) 🤔: This is like a well-maintained, certified pre-owned luxury car from a reputable brand, or a new model from a solid but less “hyped” manufacturer. It offers excellent quality and features, attracting discerning buyers looking for strong value without the absolute peak price. Negotiation is more common. Similarly, a home with some less desirable features (e.g., a quirky floorplan, smaller yard size, some outdated materials) but still in a prime location will likely sell, but expect more direct price negotiation because it will be with a single, interested buyer. The final price is more susceptible to individual buyer perception and how well its value is presented.
- Clearance (The High-Mileage Bargain) 🏷️: This mirrors an older model car, one with higher mileage, some cosmetic issues, or a less desirable make/model that needs work. It will find a buyer when the price becomes undeniably attractive, appealing to the budget conscious or those specifically looking for a project with potential, which is a much smaller buyer pool now than during COVID. A home with more significant challenges – perhaps a high-cost HOA, a floorplan that is closed off and segmented, on a busy road, an undesirable bedroom/bathroom count for the target demographic, or in clear need of updates – falls into this category. Here, price becomes the primary driver.
Your home will likely align with one of these categories. The key is not just which category, but how your agent strategically positions it within that category to attract the right buyer and maximize its perceived value.
— 🤝 —
The Critical Role of Objective Expertise (and Trusting It!)
Here’s where many home sales fail right now: lining up the property’s reality with market perception. Your home must either be physically irresistible or financially too compelling to pass up.
The challenge? Personal attachment and bias. It’s natural to love your home and see its best features. But you’re not buying your own home; a discerning buyer is. This is where the Realtor you choose is crucial. You hire us for our expertise in viewing your property through the critical lens of today’s buyer.
My role often involves providing direct, sometimes “offensive, brutally honest” opinions about your home’s current state as a buyer will perceive it. This isn’t to criticize, but to strategize. Trusting this judgment is paramount. If you’ve hired wisely, your agent’s recommendations on preparation, presentation, and pricing are designed to elevate your property into the most favorable category possible, creating demand (and offers).
— 🔑 —
Shifting Leverage: From Buyer Control to Seller Advantage
In the current SF Bay Area market, if a home isn’t compellingly presented and strategically priced, buyers generally hold more leverage. They have options, and their money talks loudest. Offers may not come, leading to extended days on the market and the dreaded price reduction cycle – effectively chasing the buyer down.
The goal of our strategy is to flip that dynamic. By meticulously preparing your home, investing in targeted marketing to reach the right buyer demographic (often beyond just local portals), and pricing it intelligently, we aim to create enough demand and competition to shift the leverage back to YOU, the seller. Multiple offers, even in a balanced market, give you control.
Are there exceptions? Of course. Some ultra-niche neighborhoods or unique luxury properties inherently have longer sales cycles. Limited budgets to upgrade the home from a clearance level to a discount or premium level will require a reality check on value. A skilled agent will identify if your home falls into such categoies and build the strategy accordingly.
— ✅ —
Accountability & The Path to Success
If you, as the seller, dictate the strategy, pricing, presentation, and upgrades against your agent’s expert recommendations, holding them accountable for a suboptimal outcome becomes very difficult.
Remember, you hire a strategic advisor to earn their commission by proving their strategy works. If you find yourself wanting to control every aspect, a discount brokerage might seem be the best fit initially, but it often proves costly in the end. What I see is that if the discount brokerage doesn’t work out, sellers will almost always seek out a premier agent with a proven track record of outperformance. Why not just start there?
Let your agent guide you. Trust their expertise. If their strategy isn’t producing results and they can’t articulate why or offer data-backed adjustments, then hold them accountable and reassess the strategy or the hire.
Your home is your fortune. It deserves an advisor committed to maximizing it through proven, bespoke strategies, no matter what the broader market dictates. We can’t control interest rates or global events, but we can control how your property is positioned and marketed to achieve its absolute best outcome.
Demand more. Expect strategic excellence. Require proof.