Keep, Refinance, Sell, or Rent Out Your Danville Home: Compare Your Options
A change in your mortgage payment can change the entire decision. Compare the monthly cost and projected financial position of keeping your loan, refinancing, selling, or renting out your home. Start with your numbers, then test the assumptions.
Estimates depend on your inputs and assumptions. They do not determine loan eligibility or whether the monthly cost fits your full household budget.
Payment shock is a sharp jump in your monthly mortgage payment, such as when an adjustable rate loan resets. The calculator shows how your payment changes and where each path leaves you 1 to 15 years out. It does not tell you which to choose.
Want a shorter first look? You can start with the quick check.
Service area: homeowners in Danville, Alamo, Blackhawk, Diablo, San Ramon, Pleasanton and the greater Bay Area.
What this calculator helps you decide
- What each of four paths costs you each month: keep your loan, refinance, sell today, or rent out your home while you rent elsewhere.
- For renting out, the full picture: your rent elsewhere plus any monthly shortfall the rent does not cover.
- Where each path leaves you at the same date, 1 to 15 years out, compared with keeping your loan.
- Whether renting now and selling later could cost you the home sale exclusion, shown as an “Exclusion not applied at sale date” flag.
- What it cannot do: it gives no verdict, does not judge loan eligibility or your full budget, does not cover missed payments or foreclosure options, and does not model Prop 19.
What you enter
- Estimated home value, mortgage balance and your current monthly principal and interest.
- Whether your rate is adjustable, the new rate and the months until it changes.
- Purchase price, the year you bought and improvements since.
- Your estimated monthly rent, and optionally what you would pay to live elsewhere.
- Whether you need the sale proceeds for your next down payment.
- Filing status, whether it is your main home, and whether you qualify for the home sale exclusion (yes, no or not sure).
- A time horizon of 1 to 15 years. You can view and change the assumptions.
What you get
| Option | Monthly cost to live | At your chosen date |
|---|---|---|
| Keep my loan (the baseline) | Your payment after the change plus ownership costs | Equity plus cash after housing costs |
| Refinance | New payment, closing costs and months to break even | Compared with keeping your loan |
| Sell today | Your cost to live elsewhere, and cash at closing | Compared with keeping your loan |
| Rent it out | Your cost to live elsewhere plus the shortfall the rent does not cover | Assumes a sale at that date, and flags “Exclusion not applied at sale date” |
A worked example
Illustrative only. Made-up round numbers for a married couple filing jointly who qualify for the home sale exclusion, using the calculator’s default 5% selling costs. Your results will differ.
| Line | Amount | How it is figured |
|---|---|---|
| Sale price (assumed) | $1,500,000 | Entered |
| Selling costs | $75,000 | 5% of $1,500,000 |
| Amount realized | $1,425,000 | $1,500,000 − $75,000 |
| Purchase price plus improvements (assumed) | $750,000 | $650,000 + $100,000 |
| Gain on the sale | $675,000 | $1,425,000 − $750,000 |
| Home sale exclusion | $500,000 | Married filing jointly, ownership and use tests met |
| Gain above the exclusion | $175,000 | $675,000 − $500,000. May be taxed federally and by California |
| Mortgage payoff (assumed) | $800,000 | Entered |
| Cash at closing before taxes | $625,000 | $1,425,000 − $800,000 |
Estimates for analysis only. Not tax, legal, lending, or investment advice.
More sources: IRS Topic 701, Sale of your home, California FTB: income from the sale of your home and the Freddie Mac mortgage rate archive.
What the comparison covers
- Your payment change.
- Refinance closing costs and months to break even.
- Sale proceeds and selling costs.
- Rental cash flow after vacancy and management.
- The home sale exclusion ownership and use tests.
- Tax on gain, rental income tax, and depreciation and its tax at sale.
- A flag for a sale within a year of buying, which is not ranked.
The tool uses 23.8% federal tax on gain, which includes the 3.8% net investment income tax, for illustration. Your rates may differ. Sources: IRS Topic 559 and Form 8960 instructions.
It uses 9.3% California tax for illustration. Your rate may differ. Source: 2025 California tax rate schedules.
Rental depreciation uses 27.5 years for the building. Source: IRS Publication 527.
What it leaves out
- Prop 19 base value transfers (see the California BOE Prop 19 page).
- Partial home sale exclusions and a full review of prior excluded sales.
- The cost of buying your next home.
- Mortgage interest and property tax deductions.
- Later rate changes on an adjustable rate loan.
- Inflation, tax brackets and the alternative minimum tax.
- Rent control and tenant law.
- Rental tax losses carried forward, which are noted but not counted.
- Loan eligibility, your full household budget, and missed payment or foreclosure options.
If you are behind on payments or expect to miss one
This calculator does not cover missed payments, repayment plans, forbearance, loan modifications or foreclosure. Contact your mortgage servicer promptly. HUD-approved housing counselors offer free or low cost help, and the CFPB explains your options.
Find a HUD-approved housing counselor (CFPB) · CFPB help for homeowners
Questions homeowners ask
What is payment shock and what can I do about it?
Payment shock is a large jump in your monthly mortgage payment, often when an adjustable rate resets. Enter your numbers to see the change and compare the monthly cost of keeping your loan, refinancing, selling, or renting out while you rent elsewhere, and where each leaves you in 1 to 15 years. It does not recommend an option or decide loan eligibility. If you may miss a payment, contact your servicer and a HUD-approved housing counselor, whose help is free or low cost.
Can I afford to keep my home after my payment goes up?
The calculator shows the monthly cost to live under each option using your numbers. It does not judge your full household budget.
Can I rent out my home and rent somewhere else myself?
Yes, that is the rent it out path. It counts your rent elsewhere plus any shortfall the rent does not cover.
Can I rent it out now and sell later?
The rent it out path assumes a sale at your chosen date. To claim the home sale exclusion, IRS Publication 523 says you must have owned the home and used it as your main home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. That window generally closes about three years after you move out, so the calculator flags “Exclusion not applied at sale date” when the sale falls past it. Confirm timing with a CPA.
Is refinancing worth it?
The calculator shows the new payment, closing costs, months to break even and the result at your chosen date. Approval and terms depend on the lender.
Does it tell me what to do?
No. It compares the options under your assumptions and does not recommend one.
Does it include Prop 19?
No. Prop 19 base value transfers are not modeled.
Is this a rent estimate?
No. You enter the rent you expect.
What if I am already behind on payments?
This calculator is not built for that. Contact your mortgage servicer and a HUD-approved housing counselor.

